Old Town Tavern in Key West
900 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040
Old Town Tavern has logged 21 inspections with 196 total violations since 2015, averaging 9.3 violations per inspection—nearly double the statewide average of 5.2. The facility was emergency-closed twice in 2015, both for roach activity. Four disciplinary actions resulted in $1,800 in combined fines. Employee health policy violations have appeared in at least 8 of the last 8 inspections, alongside recurring handwashing, chemical storage, and food contact surface violations. Propane tank violations documented in 2016 involved improper indoor storage of tanks exceeding safe capacity limits. The most recent inspection on August 18, 2025 identified 7 violations including high-priority employee health policy and time-as-control issues, with disposition Inspection Completed - No Further Action.
Most recent closure: June 16, 2015 for roach activity.
Summary generated from Florida DBPR public inspection records.
Last inspected DBPR: August 18, 2025
Old Town Tavern in Key West: Comparison to Monroe County Averages
This Facility
9.3
violations / inspection
9.3 violations per inspection
Monroe County Avg
7.04
violations / inspection
7.04 county average
This Facility
2
emergency closures
2 closures
Monroe County Avg
0.08
closures / facility
0.08 county average
Old Town Tavern in Key West: Emergency Closure History (2)
| Date | Reason | Reopened |
|---|---|---|
| Roach activity | 14:38:00 | |
| Roach activity | 11:19:00 |
Old Town Tavern in Key West: Fines & Disciplinary Actions (4)
Total fines on record: $1,800.00
| Action Date | Case Number | Fine | Violation Date | Enforcement Office |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1--2016002599 | — | Jan 20, 2016 | Fort Lauderdale | |
| 1--2015032604 | $800.00 | Jul 2, 2015 | Miami (Doral) | |
| 1--2015027256 | — | Jun 16, 2015 | Miami (Doral) | |
| 1--2015011729 | $1,000.00 | Mar 10, 2015 | Fort Lauderdale |
Old Town Tavern in Key West: Fire Safety & Life Safety Violations (3)
— 3 fire violations
— Food-Licensing Inspection · 48-04-4 · Inspection Completed - No Further Action
Inspector Observation: Propane tank (larger than 2.7 lb. water capacity/1 lb. gas capacity) located inside of the building. For reporting purposes only.
Legal Basis: Reporting: (d) The division, or its agent, shall notify the local firesafety authority or the State Fire Marshal of any readily observable violation of a rule adopted under chapter 633 which relates to public lodging establishments or public food establishments, and the identification of such violation does not require any firesafety inspection certification. For reporting purposes only.
— Complaint Full · 48-04-4 · Call Back - Extension given, pending
Inspector Observation: - From inspection on 2016-05-20: Propane tank (larger than 2.7 lb. water capacity/1 lb. gas capacity) located inside of the building. For reporting purposes only. - From follow-up inspection on 2016-05-23:
Legal Basis: Reporting: (d) The division, or its agent, shall notify the local firesafety authority or the State Fire Marshal of any readily observable violation of a rule adopted under chapter 633 which relates to public lodging establishments or public food establishments, and the identification of such violation does not require any firesafety inspection certification. For reporting purposes only.
— Complaint Full · 48-04-4 · Warning Issued
Inspector Observation: Propane tank (larger than 2.7 lb. water capacity/1 lb. gas capacity) located inside of the building. For reporting purposes only.
Legal Basis: Reporting: (d) The division, or its agent, shall notify the local firesafety authority or the State Fire Marshal of any readily observable violation of a rule adopted under chapter 633 which relates to public lodging establishments or public food establishments, and the identification of such violation does not require any firesafety inspection certification. For reporting purposes only.
Old Town Tavern in Key West: Full Inspection History — DBPR (21)
— 2 inspections12 violations · 8 high priority
— Routine - Food· 7 violations (4 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— Routine - Food· 5 violations (4 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— 2 inspections13 violations · 10 high priority
— Routine - Food· 6 violations (5 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— Routine - Food· 7 violations (5 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
Basic Violations
— 3 inspections21 violations · 15 high priority
— Routine - Food· 7 violations (4 high priority)· Administrative complaint recommended
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
Basic Violations
— Routine - Food· 8 violations (6 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— Routine - Food· 6 violations (5 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— 1 inspection7 violations · 6 high priority
— Routine - Food· 7 violations (6 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— 2 inspections14 violations · 9 high priority
— Routine - Food· 5 violations (3 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— Routine - Food· 9 violations (6 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— 4 inspections30 violations · 19 high priority
— Routine - Food· 6 violations (3 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— Routine - Food· 2 violations (1 high priority)· Call Back - Complied
— Routine - Food· 11 violations (7 high priority)· Warning Issued
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
Basic Violations
— Routine - Food· 11 violations (8 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— 4 inspections27 violations · 13 high priority
— Routine - Food· 2 violations (1 high priority)· Call Back - Complied
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— Routine - Food· 4 violations (1 high priority)· Call Back - Extension given, pending
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
Basic Violations
— Routine - Food· 18 violations (10 high priority)· Warning Issued
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
Basic Violations
— Food-Licensing Inspection· 3 violations (1 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— 2 inspections17 violations · 9 high priority
— Routine - Food· 7 violations (4 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
Basic Violations
— Complaint Full· 10 violations (5 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— 1 inspection8 violations · 4 high priority
— Food-Licensing Inspection· 8 violations (4 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
Basic Violations
Old Town Tavern in Key West: Frequently Asked Questions
- When was Old Town Tavern in Key West last inspected?
- Old Town Tavern in Key West was last inspected by Florida DBPR on August 18, 2025. The result was: Inspection Completed - No Further Action.
- When was Old Town Tavern in Key West last shut down?
- Old Town Tavern in Key West was last shut down on June 16, 2015 for roach activity. This data reflects state records at time of publication. The facility may have since resolved these issues.
- What are the most common violations at Old Town Tavern in Key West?
- The most frequently cited violations at Old Town Tavern in Key West are: Proper sewage disposal, Food contact surfaces, Proper ventilation.
- How many health inspections has Old Town Tavern in Key West had?
- Old Town Tavern in Key West has had 21 inspections on record with Florida DBPR, averaging 9.3 violations per inspection, above the statewide average of 5.2.
- What did the most recent inspection of Old Town Tavern in Key West find?
- Old Town Tavern in Key West was most recently inspected on August 18, 2025 with 7 violation(s), including 2 high-priority violation(s). Disposition: Inspection Completed - No Further Action.
- Has Old Town Tavern in Key West ever been shut down?
- Yes, Old Town Tavern in Key West has been emergency-closed 2 times by Florida DBPR inspectors.
- What does Florida violation V02 (Employee health policy) mean?
- Violation 02 (Employee health policy) is classified as a high priority violation under Florida DBPR food safety regulations. See the full explanation at floridafoodsafety.org/violation/02.
- What does Florida violation V03 (Employee health reporting) mean?
- Violation 03 (Employee health reporting) is classified as a high priority violation under Florida DBPR food safety regulations. See the full explanation at floridafoodsafety.org/violation/03.
- What does Florida violation V08 (Proper hand/arm washing) mean?
- Violation 08 (Proper hand/arm washing) is classified as a high priority violation under Florida DBPR food safety regulations. See the full explanation at floridafoodsafety.org/violation/08.
- Has Old Town Tavern in Key West had any fire safety violations?
- Yes, Old Town Tavern in Key West has 3 fire safety violation(s) on record from Florida state fire inspections.
- Has Old Town Tavern in Key West faced any disciplinary actions?
- Yes, Old Town Tavern in Key West has 4 disciplinary action(s) on record with Florida DBPR totaling $1,800.00 in fines.
- How much has Old Town Tavern in Key West been fined?
- Old Town Tavern in Key West has been fined a total of $1,800.00 across 4 disciplinary action(s) on record with Florida DBPR.
- Has Old Town Tavern in Key West operated under other names?
- Yes, this location previously operated as: McConnells Irish Pub & Grille (2016-2016), Bogarts Irish Pub and Grill (2016).
Nearby Establishments to Old Town Tavern
Editorial Standards & Data Oversight
Data Source: This report is based on official public inspection records from the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR) and the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (FDACS).
Editorial Process: Content generated using AI to synthesize complex regulatory data, then reviewed and verified for accuracy by our editorial team.
Disclaimer: All data reflects official state records at time of publication. Facilities may have since corrected cited violations, resolved enforcement actions, or changed ownership.
Editor: All content reviewed and verified by Christopher F. Nesbitt, Sr., Nationally Registered EMT & BU-trained Paralegal.
This page is maintained by FloridaFoodSafety.org and is not affiliated with Old Town Tavern. How we collect and verify this data.