Key West — Food Safety Records
Key West, Florida has 295 food establishments with 5,572 inspections on record. 3 establishments were shut down this year. The pass rate is 90.2%, above the state average of 85.7%. Inspections average 6.8 violations per visit.
Most recent closure: New York Pasta Garden in Key West, shut down August 11, 2026 for roach & fly activity.
Largest fine: $400 assessed to Banana Cafe in Key West on January 21, 2026.
Data from Florida DBPR. Updated August 2026.
Key West Restaurants: Comparison to Florida State Averages
Key West
90.2%
Pass Rate
90.2%
Florida Average
85.7%
Pass Rate
85.7%
Key West
6.8
Avg Violations / Inspection
6.8
Florida Average
4.7
Avg Violations / Inspection
4.7
Key West
1.02
Closures per 100 Facilities
1.02
Florida Average
2.04
Closures per 100 Facilities
2.04
Key West Restaurants: Recent Closures (2)
| Date | Business | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| New York Pasta Garden | Roach & fly activity | |
| Pickles Pub Sandbar | Rodent & fly activity |
Key West Restaurants: Recent Inspections (Last 30 Days)
| Date | Business | Violations | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ocean Grill | 2 | Emergency Order Callback Complied | |
| Goldman`s Bagel Deli | 7 (1 high) | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Half Shell Raw Bar | 9 (3 high) | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Beach Bar & Grill | 17 (2 high) | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Hurricane Hole | 1 | Call Back - Complied | |
| Tin Cup Chalice | 1 | Call Back - Complied | |
| Ocean Grill | 8 (5 high) | Emergency Order Callback Not Complied | |
| Shooterz | 4 | Call Back - Admin. complaint recommended | |
| Kaya Island Eats/key West Emporium | 10 (1 high) | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Island Dogs Bar | 10 (1 high) | Inspection Completed - No Further Action |
Key West Restaurants: Most Common Health Violations
| Code | Violation | Citations |
|---|---|---|
| 22 | Consumer advisory | 50,370 |
| 14 | Food contact surfaces | 44,345 |
| 36 | Proper ventilation | 41,693 |
| 08 | Proper hand/arm washing | 40,943 |
| 23 | Chemical properly stored | 35,561 |
Key West Restaurants: Disciplinary Actions & Fines
Largest Fines (Past 12 Months)
| Date | Business | Fine | Case |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 21, 2026 | Banana Cafe | $400 | 1--2025079093 |
| Jan 5, 2026 | Grand Cafe Key West | $400 | 1--2025082674 |
| Sep 10, 2025 | Thai Island Restaurant | $400 | 1--2025053285 |
| Sep 4, 2025 | Ocean Grill | $400 | 1--2025053602 |
| Sep 16, 2025 | Mangoes | $400 | 1--2025056281 |
| Dec 10, 2025 | Southernmost Pint | $160 | 1--2025078896 |
| Apr 8, 2026 | Origami | $160 | 1--2025043287 |
Key West Restaurants: Fire Safety Violations
Most Common Fire Safety Issues
| Issue | Citations |
|---|---|
| Other fire safety violation | 20 |
| Propane tank stored inside building | 16 |
| Cooking without hood suppression | 13 |
| Missing boiler certificate/report | 9 |
| Exit blocked or locked | 6 |
| Fire extinguisher in red zone | 3 |
Key West: Notable Restaurants
New York Pasta Garden
39 inspections
722 violations
2 closures
Ocean Grill
39 inspections
526 violations
2 closures
Thai Island Restaurant
25 inspections
247 violations
2 closures
Half Shell Raw Bar
36 inspections
367 violations
Docs on Duval
20 inspections
187 violations
Island Dogs Bar
24 inspections
318 violations
Key West: Restaurant Chains (DBPR)
| Chain | Locations | Violations | Closures |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hampton Inn | 2 | 152 | 0 |
| Wendys | 2 | 259 | 1 |
| Fairfield Inn | 2 | 126 | 0 |
| Subway | 2 | 96 | 0 |
| Chilis | 1 | 16 | 0 |
| Dunkin | 1 | 165 | 0 |
| Outback Steakhouse | 1 | 247 | 1 |
| Starbucks | 1 | 64 | 0 |
| Dominos | 1 | 98 | 2 |
| Haagen-dazs | 1 | 48 | 0 |
Key West Restaurant Inspections: FAQ
- How many restaurants are in Key West?
- Key West, Florida has 295 food establishments tracked by the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR).
- What is the restaurant inspection pass rate in Key West?
- The current pass rate for food establishments in Key West is 90.2%. The Florida state average is 85.7%.
- How many restaurants were shut down in Key West this year?
- 3 food establishments in Key West have been shut down by health inspectors in 2026.
- What are the most common health violations in Key West?
- The most frequently cited violations in Key West are: Consumer advisory, Food contact surfaces, Proper ventilation.
- Which restaurant chain has the most locations in Key West?
- Hampton Inn has the most locations in Key West with 2 establishments.
- What was the most recent restaurant closure in Key West?
- New York Pasta Garden in Key West was shut down on August 11, 2026 for roach & fly activity.
- How does Key West compare to the Florida state average?
- Key West has a pass rate of 90.2%, which is 4.5 percentage points above the state average of 85.7%. The average violations per inspection is 6.8 compared to the state average of 4.68.
- How often are restaurants inspected in Key West?
- Food establishments in Key West have an average of 18.9 inspections on record. Florida DBPR conducts routine inspections based on facility type and risk level.
- How much in fines have restaurants in Key West been assessed?
- Food establishments in Key West have been assessed $59,650 in fines across 170 disciplinary actions. The average fine is $357 and the largest single fine was $1,680.
- How many fire safety violations have been found in Key West restaurants?
- 67 fire safety violations have been documented across 45 food establishments in Key West. The most common issue is other fire safety violation.
In the News Key West
See all 63 stories ↓
12 Florida Keys Restaurants Cited for High-Severity Violations During Peak Tourist Week
A sushi restaurant on Southard Street drew 8 high-severity violations including unapproved food sources and parasite des…
Stories You May Have Missed
- 12 Florida Keys Restaurants Cited for High-Severity Violations During Peak Tourist Week
- Key West Pasta Restaurant Emergency-Closed for Roaches and Flies, Third Shutdown in Two Years
- 12 Florida Keys Restaurants Cited for High-Severity Violations, August 2026
- Florida Keys Restaurants Rack Up 67 High-Severity Violations in One Week
- Key West Restaurant Stayed Open With 6 High-Severity Violations, Including Contaminated Food
- Key West Waterfront Cafe Logged 6 High-Severity Violations, Stayed Open
- Key West Oyster Bar Racked Up 7 High-Severity Violations, Stayed Open
- Key West Bar Racked Up 7 High-Severity Violations, Stayed Open Anyway
- Florida Keys Restaurants Rack Up 82 High-Severity Violations in One Week
- Key West Restaurant Kept Serving With 8 High-Severity Violations, Including Unapproved Food Source
- Key West Pasta Restaurant Racked Up 9 High-Severity Violations and Stayed Open
- 12 Florida Keys Restaurants Cited for High-Severity Violations, Aug. 17-23
- 12 Florida Keys Restaurants Cited for High-Severity Violations During Peak Tourist Week
- Key West's Sunset Pier Racked Up 6 High-Severity Violations, Stayed Open
- Key West Bar Closed for Rodents and Flies, 486 Violations in Its Record
Key West Restaurants & Food Establishments (295)
New York Pasta Garden 2 closures
1075 DUVAL C1, Key West
39 inspections · 722 violations · Last: Aug 2026Ocean Grill 2 closures
1075 DUVAL ST STE C12, Key West
39 inspections · 526 violations · Last: Aug 2026Thai Island Restaurant 2 closures
711 EISENHOWER DR, Key West
25 inspections · 247 violations · Last: Jul 2025Old Town Tavern 2 closures
900 DUVAL ST, Key West
21 inspections · 196 violations · Last: Aug 2025Smoked BBQ 2 closures
1801 N ROOSEVELT BLVD, Key West
24 inspections · 99 violations · Last: Aug 2026Domino's Pizza 2 closures
2704 N ROOSEVELT BLVD, Key West
17 inspections · 98 violations · Last: May 2026Kennedy Cafe 1 closure
924-A KENNEDY DR, Key West
33 inspections · 589 violations · Last: Jul 2026Pickles Pub Sandbar 1 closure
511 GREENE ST #101, Key West
29 inspections · 486 violations · Last: Aug 2026Grand Cafe Key West 1 closure
314 DUVAL ST, Key West
30 inspections · 432 violations · Last: Nov 2025Tong's Garden 1 closure
1458 KENNEDY DR, Key West
31 inspections · 351 violations · Last: Aug 2026Schooner Wharf Bar 1 closure
202 R WILLIAM ST, Key West
30 inspections · 345 violations · Last: Nov 2025Conchiglia 1 closure
816 DUVAL ST, Key West
29 inspections · 341 violations · Last: Aug 2026Hogfish Bar and Grill 1 closure
6810 FRONT ST, Key West
30 inspections · 335 violations · Last: Aug 2026Hurricane Hole 1 closure
5130 OVERSEAS HWY, Key West
26 inspections · 317 violations · Last: Aug 2026Viva Argentinian Steakhouse 1 closure
903 DUVAL ST, Key West
23 inspections · 302 violations · Last: Jul 2026Karlitas Cafe 1 closure
934 TRUMAN AVE, Key West
30 inspections · 301 violations · Last: Jul 2026Mangoes 1 closure
700 DUVAL ST, Key West
26 inspections · 290 violations · Last: Jul 2026Tin Cup Chalice 1 closure
2001 S ROOSEVELT BLVD, Key West
29 inspections · 281 violations · Last: Aug 2026Docs on Duval 1 closure
712 DUVAL ST, Key West
31 inspections · 274 violations · Last: Dec 2025Waterfront Brewery 1 closure
201 WILLIAM STREET SUITE A, Key West
25 inspections · 258 violations · Last: Aug 2026