South Island Pizza in Islamorada
80925 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
South Island Pizza in Islamorada has been cited for 83 violations across 22 inspections, averaging 3.8 violations per inspection — below the statewide average of 5.2. However, the facility has accumulated a pattern of high-priority violations including improper hand washing, shell stock handling, food temperature control, and chemical storage across multiple inspections. The December 2025 inspection documented hand washing violations and shell stock requirement failures that recurred from the August 2025 inspection. An administrative complaint was recommended following the November 2023 inspection for cooking temperature and chemical storage violations. The facility incurred $440 in disciplinary fines. The most recent inspection on December 12, 2025 was completed with no further action required.
Summary generated from Florida DBPR public inspection records.
Last inspected DBPR: December 12, 2025
South Island Pizza in Islamorada: Comparison to Monroe County Averages
South Island Pizza in Islamorada: Fines & Disciplinary Actions (1)
Total fines on record: $440.00
| Action Date | Case Number | Fine | Violation Date | Enforcement Office |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1--2018001599 | $440.00 | Jan 19, 2018 | Tampa |
South Island Pizza in Islamorada: Full Inspection History — DBPR (22)
— 2 inspections7 violations · 4 high priority
— Routine - Food· 3 violations (2 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Basic Violations
— Food-Licensing Inspection· 4 violations (2 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
Basic Violations
— 4 inspections7 violations · 4 high priority
— Food-Licensing Inspection· 0 violations · Call Back - Complied
No violations recorded for this inspection.
— Food-Licensing Inspection· 1 violations · Call Back - Extension given, pending
Basic Violations
— Food-Licensing Inspection· 1 violations · Warning Issued
Basic Violations
— Routine - Food· 5 violations (4 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— 2 inspections8 violations · 4 high priority
— Routine - Food· 4 violations (2 high priority)· Administrative complaint recommended
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
Basic Violations
— Routine - Food· 4 violations (2 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
Basic Violations
— 2 inspections6 violations · 5 high priority
— Routine - Food· 3 violations (2 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— Routine - Food· 3 violations (3 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
— 2 inspections6 violations · 5 high priority
— Routine - Food· 3 violations (2 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— Routine - Food· 3 violations (3 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
— 2 inspections5 violations · 4 high priority
— Routine - Food· 3 violations (3 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
— Routine - Food· 2 violations (1 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
— 3 inspections3 violations · 1 high priority
— Routine - Food· 0 violations · Call Back - Complied
No violations recorded for this inspection.
— Routine - Food· 2 violations (1 high priority)· Warning Issued
— Food-Licensing Inspection· 1 violations · Inspection Completed - No Further Action
Intermediate Violations
— 4 inspections12 violations · 5 high priority
— Routine - Food· 2 violations · Call Back - Admin. complaint recommended
— Routine - Food· 2 violations · Call Back - Extension given, pending
— Routine - Food· 6 violations (3 high priority)· Warning Issued
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
Basic Violations
— Food-Licensing Inspection· 2 violations (2 high priority)· Inspection Completed - No Further Action
— 1 inspection10 violations · 7 high priority
— Routine - Food· 10 violations (7 high priority)· Warning Issued
High Priority Violations
Intermediate Violations
Basic Violations
South Island Pizza in Islamorada: Frequently Asked Questions
- When was South Island Pizza in Islamorada last inspected?
- South Island Pizza in Islamorada was last inspected by Florida DBPR on December 12, 2025. The result was: Inspection Completed - No Further Action.
- What are the most common violations at South Island Pizza in Islamorada?
- The most frequently cited violations at South Island Pizza in Islamorada are: Outer openings protected, Premises clean, Food in good condition.
- How many health inspections has South Island Pizza in Islamorada had?
- South Island Pizza in Islamorada has had 22 inspections on record with Florida DBPR, averaging 3.8 violations per inspection, below the statewide average of 5.2.
- What did the most recent inspection of South Island Pizza in Islamorada find?
- South Island Pizza in Islamorada was most recently inspected on December 12, 2025 with 4 violation(s), including 1 high-priority violation(s). Disposition: Inspection Completed - No Further Action.
- Has South Island Pizza in Islamorada ever been shut down?
- No, South Island Pizza in Islamorada has no emergency closures on record with Florida DBPR.
- What does Florida violation V08 (Proper hand/arm washing) mean?
- Violation 08 (Proper hand/arm washing) is classified as a high priority violation under Florida DBPR food safety regulations. See the full explanation at floridafoodsafety.org/violation/08.
- What does Florida violation V12 (Shell stock requirements) mean?
- Violation 12 (Shell stock requirements) is classified as a high priority violation under Florida DBPR food safety regulations. See the full explanation at floridafoodsafety.org/violation/12.
- What does Florida violation V53 (Outer openings protected) mean?
- Violation 53 (Outer openings protected) is classified as a basic priority violation under Florida DBPR food safety regulations. See the full explanation at floridafoodsafety.org/violation/53.
- Has South Island Pizza in Islamorada faced any disciplinary actions?
- Yes, South Island Pizza in Islamorada has 1 disciplinary action(s) on record with Florida DBPR totaling $440.00 in fines.
- How much has South Island Pizza in Islamorada been fined?
- South Island Pizza in Islamorada has been fined a total of $440.00 across 1 disciplinary action(s) on record with Florida DBPR.
Nearby Establishments to South Island Pizza
Editorial Standards & Data Oversight
Data Source: This report is based on official public inspection records from the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR) and the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (FDACS).
Editorial Process: Content generated using AI to synthesize complex regulatory data, then reviewed and verified for accuracy by our editorial team.
Disclaimer: All data reflects official state records at time of publication. Facilities may have since corrected cited violations, resolved enforcement actions, or changed ownership.
Editor: All content reviewed and verified by Christopher F. Nesbitt, Sr., Nationally Registered EMT & BU-trained Paralegal.
This page is maintained by FloridaFoodSafety.org and is not affiliated with South Island Pizza. How we collect and verify this data.