Islamorada — Food Safety Records: DBPR & FDACS
Islamorada, Florida has 71 food establishments with 1,371 inspections on record. The pass rate is 98.4%, above the state average of 86.2%. Inspections average 7.1 violations per visit.
Largest fine: $160 assessed to Canoe Club in Islamorada on March 25, 2026.
Data from Florida DBPR (restaurants) and FDACS (retail food). Updated April 2026.
Islamorada Restaurants: Comparison to Florida State Averages
Islamorada Restaurants: Recent Inspections (Last 30 Days)
| Date | Business | Violations | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marathon Bagel Co LLC @ Islamorada | 4 (2 high) | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Three Waters Resort Marina - Main Kitchen/tiki Bar/kokomos | 6 (2 high) | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Italian Food Company | 3 (1 high) | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Casa Morada | 4 | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Chesapeake Beach Resort | 3 (1 high) | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Punta Morada | 0 | Inspection Completed - No Further Action |
Islamorada Restaurants: Most Common Health Violations
| Code | Violation | Citations |
|---|---|---|
| 31 | Clean multi-use utensils | 357 |
| 22 | Consumer advisory | 327 |
| 08 | Proper hand/arm washing | 295 |
| 29 | Proper sewage disposal | 278 |
| 14 | Food contact surfaces | 239 |
Islamorada Restaurants: Disciplinary Actions & Fines
Largest Fines (Past 12 Months)
| Date | Business | Fine | Case |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mar 25, 2026 | Canoe Club | $160 | 1--2026011914 |
Islamorada Restaurants: Fire Safety Violations
Most Common Fire Safety Issues
| Issue | Citations |
|---|---|
| Fire extinguisher in red zone | 12 |
| Propane tank stored inside building | 8 |
| Other fire safety violation | 7 |
| Exit blocked or locked | 2 |
| Missing boiler certificate/report | 1 |
Islamorada Retail Food: FDACS Inspection Records
In addition to restaurants, Florida's Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (FDACS) inspects grocery stores, markets, gas station food sections, and other retail food establishments. Islamorada has 18 FDACS-regulated facilities with 24 inspections on record and 7 stop-sale orders issued.
Islamorada FDACS: Recent Stop-Sale Orders
A stop-sale order prohibits a retail food establishment from selling specific products found to be unsafe, improperly stored, mislabeled, or non-compliant with Florida food code. Products may be embargoed, destroyed, or returned to the distributor.
| Date | Facility | Product | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Islamorada-gas-grocery-LLC-387873 | Brand Name: (Lot #:) | 581.217(7)(e), F.S.* Distribution/Retail Sale and Advertising/Marketing | |
| Islamorada-gas-grocery-LLC-387873 | Brand Name: (Lot #:) | 581.217(7)(e), F.S.* Distribution/Retail Sale and Advertising/Marketing | |
| Islamorada-gas-grocery-LLC-387873 | Brand Name: (Lot #:) | 581.217(7)(e), F.S.* Distribution/Retail Sale and Advertising/Marketing | |
| Islamorada-gas-grocery-LLC-387873 | Brand Name: (Lot #:) | FS 500.04; FS 500.11 Misbranded.* Labeling | |
| Islamorada-gas-grocery-LLC-387873 | Brand Name: (Lot #:) | FS 500.04; FS 500.11 Misbranded.* Labeling | |
| Islamorada-gas-grocery-LLC-387873 | Brand Name: (Lot #:) | FS 500; FAC 5K-4 Violation of Florida Food Law.* Container Requirements | |
| Islamorada-gas-grocery-LLC-387873 | Brand Name: (Lot #:) | FS 500.04; FS 500.172 Unsanitary Equipment.* Protection From Contamination: Food… |
Browse all FDACS stop-sale order categories →
Islamorada FDACS: Most Cited Code Violations
Islamorada: Notable Restaurants
Lorelei of Islamorada
Meat Eatery and Taproom
Hungry Tarpon Restaurant
Marker 88
Marathon Bagel Co LLC @ Islamorada
Three Waters Resort Marina - Main Kitchen/tiki Bar/kokomos
Islamorada: Restaurant Chains (DBPR)
| Chain | Locations | Violations | Closures |
|---|---|---|---|
| Starbucks | 1 | 77 | 0 |
| Subway | 1 | 74 | 0 |
| Sushi Sake | 1 | 227 | 0 |
| Wendys | 1 | 84 | 0 |
Islamorada Restaurant Inspections: FAQ
- How many restaurants are in Islamorada?
- Islamorada, Florida has 71 food establishments tracked by the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR).
- What is the restaurant inspection pass rate in Islamorada?
- The current pass rate for food establishments in Islamorada is 98.4%. The Florida state average is 86.2%.
- What are the most common health violations in Islamorada?
- The most frequently cited violations in Islamorada are: Clean multi-use utensils, Consumer advisory, Proper hand/arm washing.
- Which restaurant chain has the most locations in Islamorada?
- Starbucks has the most locations in Islamorada with 1 establishments.
- How does Islamorada compare to the Florida state average?
- Islamorada has a pass rate of 98.4%, which is 12.2 percentage points above the state average of 86.2%. The average violations per inspection is 7.1 compared to the state average of 4.67.
- How often are restaurants inspected in Islamorada?
- Food establishments in Islamorada have an average of 19.3 inspections on record. Florida DBPR conducts routine inspections based on facility type and risk level.
- How much in fines have restaurants in Islamorada been assessed?
- Food establishments in Islamorada have been assessed $8,215 in fines across 32 disciplinary actions. The average fine is $257 and the largest single fine was $600.
- How many fire safety violations have been found in Islamorada restaurants?
- 30 fire safety violations have been documented across 18 food establishments in Islamorada. The most common issue is fire extinguisher in red zone.
- Are grocery stores and retail food stores in Islamorada inspected?
- Yes. The Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (FDACS) inspects retail food establishments — grocery stores, gas station food sections, markets, and convenience stores. Islamorada, Florida has 18 FDACS-regulated retail food facilities with 24 inspections on record.
- How many FDACS stop-sale orders have been issued in Islamorada?
- FDACS has issued 7 stop-sale orders at retail food establishments in Islamorada, including 7 in 2026. A stop-sale order prohibits a facility from selling specific products found to be unsafe, mislabeled, or non-compliant with Florida food code.
Islamorada Restaurants & Food Establishments (70)
Nikai
81801 OVERSEAS HWY, Islamorada
23 inspections · 98 violations · Last: Jan 2026Paul's Beach Bar & Grill
84801 S OLD HWY, Islamorada
20 inspections · 96 violations · Last: Aug 2025Conference Center
82100 OVERSEAS HWY, Islamorada
20 inspections · 90 violations · Last: Jan 2026Wendy's Restaurant
82201 OVERSEAS HWY, Islamorada
17 inspections · 84 violations · Last: Jan 2026South Island Pizza
80925 OVERSEAS HWY, Islamorada
22 inspections · 83 violations · Last: Dec 2025Starbucks
84001 OVERSEAS HIGHWAY, Islamorada
20 inspections · 77 violations · Last: Jan 2026Subway #59987
82685 OVERSEAS HWY STE G, Islamorada
14 inspections · 74 violations · Last: Oct 2025Canoe Club
80500 OVERSEAS HWY, Islamorada
22 inspections · 73 violations · Last: Dec 2025Hadley House Resort
82749 OVERSEAS HWY, Islamorada
16 inspections · 68 violations · Last: Dec 2025Punta Morada
81001 OVERSEAS HWY STE 3, Islamorada
14 inspections · 59 violations · Last: Mar 2026Woody's
81908 OVERSEAS HWY, Islamorada
12 inspections · 48 violations · Last: Sep 2024Shima
88005 OVERSEAS HWY SUITE 16 & 17, Islamorada
8 inspections · 45 violations · Last: Nov 2025Italian Food Company
82779 OVERSEAS HWY, Islamorada
7 inspections · 38 violations · Last: Apr 2026Sunset Lounge
80460 OVERSEAS HWY, Islamorada
12 inspections · 37 violations · Last: Oct 2025Papa Joe's Waterfront
79786 OVERSEAS HWY, Islamorada
8 inspections · 34 violations · Last: Jan 2026Chesapeake Beach Resort
83409 OVERSEAS HWY, Islamorada
7 inspections · 34 violations · Last: Mar 2026Islamorada Wine Co
80925 OVERSEAS HWY UNIT 3, Islamorada
14 inspections · 32 violations · Last: Dec 2024Mr C's Gourmet Ice Cream Sorbet and Gelatos
86701 OVERSEAS HWY STE 1, Islamorada
6 inspections · 30 violations · Last: Sep 2025Fisher Inn Resort
84951 OVERSEAS HWY, Islamorada
5 inspections · 23 violations · Last: Sep 2025Marathon Bagel Co LLC @ Islamorada
86701 OVERSEAS HIGHWAY STE 5 & 6, Islamorada
8 inspections · 23 violations · Last: Apr 2026