Islamorada — Food Safety Records
Islamorada, Florida has 63 food establishments with 1,433 inspections on record. 2 establishments were shut down this year. The pass rate is 95.2%, above the state average of 85.7%. Inspections average 7.1 violations per visit.
Most recent closure: Hungry Tarpon Restaurant in Islamorada, shut down June 18, 2026 for rodent & fly activity.
Largest fine: $400 assessed to Meat Eatery and Taproom in Islamorada on May 19, 2026.
Data from Florida DBPR. Updated September 2026.
Islamorada Restaurants: Comparison to Florida State Averages
Islamorada
95.2%
Pass Rate
95.2%
Florida Average
85.7%
Pass Rate
85.7%
Islamorada
7.1
Avg Violations / Inspection
7.1
Florida Average
4.7
Avg Violations / Inspection
4.7
Islamorada
3.17
Closures per 100 Facilities
3.17
Florida Average
2.14
Closures per 100 Facilities
2.14
Islamorada Restaurants: Recent Closures (1)
| Date | Business | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Hungry Tarpon Restaurant | Rodent & fly activity |
Islamorada Restaurants: Recent Inspections (Last 30 Days)
| Date | Business | Violations | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lorelei of Islamorada | 9 (4 high) | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Canoe Club | 7 | Warning Issued | |
| Marathon Bagel Co LLC @ Islamorada | 2 | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Nikai | 5 (1 high) | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Kindler | 7 (2 high) | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Chesapeake Beach Resort | 6 (1 high) | Warning Issued | |
| Papa Joe's Waterfront | 7 (1 high) | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Conference Center | 8 (2 high) | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Elements Lounge and Restaurant | 6 | Inspection Completed - No Further Action | |
| Tides Beachsidebar & Grill | 8 (1 high) | Warning Issued |
Islamorada Restaurants: Most Common Health Violations
| Code | Violation | Citations |
|---|---|---|
| 22 | Consumer advisory | 11,305 |
| 31 | Clean multi-use utensils | 11,169 |
| 29 | Proper sewage disposal | 8,929 |
| 08 | Proper hand/arm washing | 8,761 |
| 14 | Food contact surfaces | 7,343 |
Islamorada Restaurants: Disciplinary Actions & Fines
Largest Fines (Past 12 Months)
| Date | Business | Fine | Case |
|---|---|---|---|
| May 19, 2026 | Meat Eatery and Taproom | $400 | 1--2026026005 |
| Mar 25, 2026 | Canoe Club | $160 | 1--2026011914 |
Islamorada Restaurants: Fire Safety Violations
Most Common Fire Safety Issues
| Issue | Citations |
|---|---|
| Fire extinguisher in red zone | 12 |
| Propane tank stored inside building | 8 |
| Other fire safety violation | 7 |
| Exit blocked or locked | 2 |
| Missing boiler certificate/report | 1 |
Islamorada: Notable Restaurants
Hungry Tarpon Restaurant
39 inspections
481 violations
1 closures
Meat Eatery and Taproom
39 inspections
463 violations
1 closures
Lorelei of Islamorada
29 inspections
282 violations
1 closures
Swordfish Grill at Budnmarys
36 inspections
184 violations
Marathon Bagel Co LLC @ Islamorada
9 inspections
25 violations
Canoe Club
23 inspections
80 violations
Islamorada: Restaurant Chains (DBPR)
| Chain | Locations | Violations | Closures |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wendys | 1 | 85 | 0 |
| Sushi Sake | 1 | 235 | 0 |
| Subway | 1 | 74 | 0 |
| Starbucks | 1 | 77 | 0 |
Islamorada Restaurant Inspections: FAQ
- How many restaurants are in Islamorada?
- Islamorada, Florida has 63 food establishments tracked by the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR).
- What is the restaurant inspection pass rate in Islamorada?
- The current pass rate for food establishments in Islamorada is 95.2%. The Florida state average is 85.7%.
- How many restaurants were shut down in Islamorada this year?
- 2 food establishments in Islamorada have been shut down by health inspectors in 2026.
- What are the most common health violations in Islamorada?
- The most frequently cited violations in Islamorada are: Consumer advisory, Clean multi-use utensils, Proper sewage disposal.
- Which restaurant chain has the most locations in Islamorada?
- Wendys has the most locations in Islamorada with 1 establishments.
- What was the most recent restaurant closure in Islamorada?
- Hungry Tarpon Restaurant in Islamorada was shut down on June 18, 2026 for rodent & fly activity.
- How does Islamorada compare to the Florida state average?
- Islamorada has a pass rate of 95.2%, which is 9.5 percentage points above the state average of 85.7%. The average violations per inspection is 7.1 compared to the state average of 4.68.
- How often are restaurants inspected in Islamorada?
- Food establishments in Islamorada have an average of 22.7 inspections on record. Florida DBPR conducts routine inspections based on facility type and risk level.
- How much in fines have restaurants in Islamorada been assessed?
- Food establishments in Islamorada have been assessed $9,875 in fines across 36 disciplinary actions. The average fine is $282 and the largest single fine was $1,120.
- How many fire safety violations have been found in Islamorada restaurants?
- 30 fire safety violations have been documented across 18 food establishments in Islamorada. The most common issue is fire extinguisher in red zone.
In the News Islamorada
See all 9 stories ↓
Islamorada Seafood Spot Racked Up 6 High-Severity Violations, Stayed Open
Reel Catch in Islamorada drew 6 high-severity violations July 17, including undercooking and illness-reporting failures,…
Stories You May Have Missed
- Islamorada Seafood Spot Racked Up 6 High-Severity Violations, Stayed Open
- Islamorada Restaurant Racked Up 6 High-Severity Violations, Stayed Open
- Hungry Tarpon in Islamorada Emergency-Closed for Rodents and Flies
- Hog Heaven in Islamorada Racked Up 7 High-Severity Violations, Stayed Open
- Square Grouper Islamorada Racked Up 6 High-Severity Violations, Stayed Open
- Wahoo's Bar and Grille Racked Up 6 High-Severity Violations in Islamorada and Stayed Open
- Islamorada Fine Dining Spot Racked Up 7 High-Severity Violations, Stayed Open
- Islamorada Taproom Emergency-Closed for Roach and Rodent Activity, April 2026
- Islamorada Waterfront Restaurant Stayed Open With 7 High-Severity Violations
Islamorada Restaurants & Food Establishments (63)
Marathon Bagel Co LLC @ Islamorada
86701 OVERSEAS HIGHWAY STE 5 & 6, Islamorada
9 inspections · 25 violations · Last: Aug 2026Islamorada Pizza Company
84341 OVERSEAS HWY, Islamorada
4 inspections · 14 violations · Last: Jul 2026Islamorada Fishing Club
104 MADEIRA RD, Islamorada
2 inspections · 8 violations · Last: Apr 2026